Are biofuels bad?
I wouldn’t suggest that we keep our biofuel policy the way it is by using subsidized corn rather than cellulostic ethanol, but I do think it is way too early to call the whole biofuel experiment a failure.
I full heartedly agree with this statement, (and the sections I didn’t copy as well). I think it is important that the criticisms of this current generation of biofuels is well publicized though. This may sound paranoid, but the Ethanol Lobby is a relatively powerful lobby, and if Ethanol is only received as our Saviour bringing energy independence, then I think we could have a problem.
Another problem, or potential problem, is that the US Government has ordered that Ethanol production be doubled by 2015.
And finally another negative about ethanol that you missed, is that because of the fertilizers used in growing corn, the runoff can endanger water quality. Granted these are all concerns and critiques about how biofuels are currently being produced, but it would seem that unless there is a critical voice about corn ethanol now then the status quo may become entrenched and then we have lost the opportunity for real change.
Grist has an excellent article summarizing the current situation with corn ethanol here.


